Skip to content

The Bunyip

DiscussionHistory

The animal in the water

The bunyip belongs to Aboriginal tradition across a wide stretch of the continent — a creature of swamps, billabongs, creeks and waterholes, with a name traced to the Wemba-Wemba and Wergaia languages of what is now Victoria. It was in the country long before any of the paperwork this article is about.

The word reached colonial print early. In 1812 the Sydney Gazette carried the spelling "bahnyip", in an account from James Ives of a large black animal like a seal, with a voice that carried badly enough to frighten people who knew the river.

The description that fixed the creature in the settler imagination came thirty-three years later. On 2 July 1845 the Geelong Advertiser and Squatters' Advocate ran a piece on its second page headed "Wonderful Discovery of a new Animal", reporting a bone found near Djillong — Geelong — and shown to a Wathaurong man, who recognised it at once and, asked to draw the animal, did so without hesitation. The paper also carried an account of a woman killed by one, and the testimony it called the most direct evidence of all: a man named Mumbowran, who showed several deep wounds on his breast and attributed them to the animal's claws. The creature as that article described it united the characteristics of a bird and of an alligator — an emu-like head, a long bill, twelve or thirteen feet tall standing up — and killed by hugging.

It is, as far as anyone has established, the first time the word appears in writing anywhere.

Seven years later the biography of William Buckley, the escaped convict who lived thirty years with the Wathaurong, recorded something far less cinematic. At Lake Moodewarri he had seen an animal about the size of a full-grown calf, and he was careful about the limits of what he had seen: he could never see any part, except the back. No one he asked had seen the head or the tail either.

Why this is in the archive

Not for the creature. What puts the bunyip here is that twice, in the 1840s, colonial Australia believed it was holding physical proof of an unknown animal — and that the two objects concerned had very different afterlives, neither of which is what the story needs.

The first came out of the Hawkesbury River in 1841 and was sent to Hobart, to the Royal Society of Tasmania, to be looked at.

The second was found about five years later by a squatter named Athol T. Fletcher, on the bank of the Murrumbidgee. In 1847 it went on show at the Colonial Museum of Sydney — the institution that is now the Australian Museum — and it worked exactly as a relic is supposed to work. Sydney queued for it. The press noted that reports of sightings rose while it was on display.

What the examination said

On 7 July 1847, while the thing was still on show, the naturalist William Sharp Macleay published "On the Skull Now Exhibited at the Colonial Museum of Sydney" in the Sydney Morning Herald. He had already examined the Hawkesbury skull from 1841, judged the new one to be the same sort of object, and concluded that both were the misshapen foetus of a mare. He reached for the principle that nature does not make jumps — natura non facit saltus — which is to say that a continent does not produce one animal unlike everything else on it and then stop.

Later retellings have rendered his conclusion variously as a foal, a calf, and in at least one colonial account a young camel. The disagreement is worth noticing, because it is a fair measure of how thin the paper trail is around an object everybody had seen.

No evidence has been produced since for a large unknown animal in Australian inland waters. There are no bones, no carcass, and no specimen that has survived examination.

The two specimens, afterwards

This is the part of the record that actually rewards suspicion, and it does not reward it in the direction the story wants.

Fletcher's skull — the one Sydney queued for, the one Macleay wrote up — is gone. It has since become lost. There is no catalogue entry to visit and nothing to re-examine, and on a different set of facts that would be the whole article: the proof went into a museum and came out of history.

It does not work as a suppression, because the examination outlived the object. Macleay published before the skull vanished, in a daily newspaper, under his own name, with his reasoning on the page. Whatever became of the specimen, the thing a cover-up would need to remove — the finding — was already in the public record and is still readable.

The second object did survive, and it is the stranger of the two. The 1841 Hawkesbury skull is in the Macleay Museum at the University of Sydney, catalogued under the registration number MAMU NHM.45 and mounted in a tall ornate nineteenth-century cabinet. Its typed label reads: A bunyip's head, New South Wales. 1841.

In 2018 the historian Penny Edmonds published a description of what is inside that label. It is a confected creature: a deformed foal's skull and skin, worked up with horse-bone, plaster and fur by a taxidermist into a one-eyed head with a long jaw, fawn-red hair and ears drooping backwards. It is not a found thing that was misread. It is a made thing.

So the surviving bunyip in an Australian museum is a manufactured object displayed under its own name, and has been for well over a century. Nobody hid it. It is in a glass case with a label on it.

The explanations that need no cover-up

Two of them have real standing, and both are more interesting than a conspiracy, because both treat the tradition as carrying accurate information rather than inventing a monster.

The first is zoological. In Bunyips and Billabongs (1933) Charles Fenner argued that seals worked their way a long way up the Murray and the Darling, and that a large dark animal with a loud voice, surfacing in fresh water hundreds of miles inland where nothing of the kind belongs, is a sufficient account of what people kept reporting. It fits the 1812 description — like a seal, with a terrible voice — almost too neatly, since that account says so in as many words.

The second is deeper. George Bennett of the Australian Museum put it formally in 1871, and the palaeontologists Pat Vickers-Rich and Neil Archbold revisited it cautiously in the early 1990s: that the tradition preserves knowledge of Australia's extinct megafauna. Diprotodon, named by Richard Owen in 1838, was a marsupial the size of a hippopotamus whose remains turn up in exactly the waterholes and dry lake beds the stories attach to. On this reading the Aboriginal account of a very large animal in the water was a true statement about a real creature, held across a span of time that colonial naturalists had no framework for and were in no position to assess.

Which inverts the usual shape of a story like this. The dismissal in the 1840s ran one way only: men examining a skull in Sydney were taken to be doing science, and the people who had been naming the animal for generations were taken to be reporting a superstition. The strongest surviving explanations for the bunyip both suggest the informants were the ones conveying something factual.

What became of the word

The last documented turn is the one that gives the whole episode away.

By the 1850s, in Australian English, a bunyip was an impostor. The word had come to mean a pretender, a humbug, something presenting itself as more than it was — a sense now obsolete, which is why it reads oddly today.

On 15 August 1853, Daniel Deniehy used it in public against W. C. Wentworth's proposal for a colonial upper house of hereditary peers, on the English model. He called the intended nobility a bunyip aristocracy. The phrase did its work; the hereditary chamber was not created, and the insult has stayed in Australian political language ever since, used from the floor as recently as Paul Keating's attacks on the Liberal opposition in the early 1990s.

So the creature colonial Australia went looking for in the river, and twice thought it had in a box, ended up as the national word for a counterfeit. Nothing was suppressed. The archive is open, the finding is published, the manufactured specimen is on a shelf with its own label, and the name has been doing duty as a term for a fake for a hundred and seventy years.

Timeline of Events

—
  1. 1812-01-01
    The word reaches print

    The spelling "bahnyip" appears in the Sydney Gazette. James Ives describes a large black animal like a seal, with a voice that carried.

  2. 1841-01-01
    A skull comes out of the Hawkesbury

    The first of the two specimens is recovered and sent to the Royal Society of Tasmania in Hobart to be examined.

  3. 1845-07-02
    "Wonderful Discovery of a new Animal"

    The Geelong Advertiser and Squatters' Advocate runs the first known written use of the word, after a bone found near Geelong is shown to a Wathaurong man who identifies it and draws the animal without hesitation.

  4. 1846-01-01
    Fletcher's find on the Murrumbidgee

    The squatter Athol T. Fletcher recovers a strangely formed skull from the riverbank. It travels before it settles.

  5. 1847-07-07
    Macleay publishes on the skull

    While the specimen is on show in Sydney, William Sharp Macleay's "On the Skull Now Exhibited at the Colonial Museum of Sydney" appears in the Sydney Morning Herald, concluding it is the misshapen foetus of a mare.

  6. 1852-01-01
    Buckley's account

    The biography of William Buckley records an animal at Lake Moodewarri about the size of a full-grown calf, of which he says he could never see any part except the back.

  7. 1853-08-15
    The name becomes an insult

    Daniel Deniehy derides W. C. Wentworth's proposed hereditary upper house as a "bunyip aristocracy". The phrase outlives the proposal.

  8. 1871-01-01
    The folk-memory idea is put formally

    George Bennett of the Australian Museum connects the tradition to Australia's extinct marsupials.

  9. 1933-01-01
    Bunyips and Billabongs

    Charles Fenner argues that seals working their way up the Murray and the Darling account for what settlers reported seeing.

  10. 2018-11-01
    The surviving specimen is traced

    Penny Edmonds publishes an account of the Macleay Museum object, describing a confected creature of foal skull and skin, horse-bone, plaster and fur, under a typed label reading "A bunyip's head, New South Wales. 1841".

Categories

Sources & References

  1. Penny Edmonds(2018)Australian Humanities Review 63
  2. (1845)Trove, National Library of Australia
  3. (1847)Trove, National Library of Australia
  4. primaryThe Bunyip
    Uncle David TournierDjillong (Wathaurong)
  5. Australian Dictionary of Biography, Australian National University
  6. referenceBunyip
    Wikipedia
  7. Wikipedia
  8. referenceDiprotodon
    Wikipedia
Field Assessment0 readings

Truth Meter

Unrated
CredibleDisputed

From the Archive

Last updated November 6, 2026. Community-maintained and reviewed under our Editorial Standards.