Category File
United States
58 documented theories filed under this subject.
- The "Wild West" Staged ShowsThis theory argues that Buffalo Bill’s Wild West shows were more than entertainment and quietly screened or recruited young men for a hidden paramilitary network. It draws on the show’s documented use of military drills, battle reenactments, Rough Riders, and later preparedness pageants, all of which gave the productions a martial tone. What is documented is overt military spectacle and patriotic messaging; what remains unproven is the claim that the shows functioned as a covert recruitment pipeline for an undeclared force.
- The "Texas" Independence HoaxThis theory argues that the Texas Revolution was less a genuine revolt than a land-speculation operation backed by Eastern money, with New York interests allegedly fabricating or exaggerating Alamo reports to generate support and raise land values. It attaches itself to real speculation, fundraising, and political maneuvering around Texas, all of which are historically documented. The unsupported leap is the claim that the revolution as a whole was staged and that the Alamo narrative was knowingly faked as part of a coordinated investor fraud.
- The "Statue of Liberty" ExplosivesThis theory holds that the base of the Statue of Liberty was not simply a pedestal within Fort Wood but an active or secretly maintained gunpowder magazine. The story is rooted in a real military past: Liberty Island housed a fort, and Fort Wood contained powder-magazine structures before the monument era. The unsupported leap is the claim that the statue’s base secretly continued to serve as an explosives depot after the monument’s dedication.
- The "Lincoln" Fake DeathThis theory claims that Abraham Lincoln did not die after the shooting at Ford’s Theatre but was quietly removed from public view and hidden in a secret Illinois bunker for the rest of his life. It contradicts the well-documented medical and eyewitness record of Lincoln’s death on April 15, 1865, yet it borrows energy from later anxieties over stolen remains, secret burials, and repeated public fascination with verifying the body. In that sense, the theory survives by attaching itself to real episodes of tomb security and post-assassination rumor rather than to direct evidence of survival.
- The "Jesse James" Robin Hood MythThis theory recasts Jesse James from guerrilla-turned-outlaw into a covert Confederate intelligence operative whose robberies and public image served a larger postwar mission. It draws plausibility from James’s genuine Civil War service in pro-Confederate guerrilla bands and from the active role Southern journalists played in mythologizing him afterward. The best-supported part of the story is his connection to ex-Confederate networks and Lost Cause propaganda; the least-supported part is the idea that he was functioning as a disciplined intelligence officer rather than a criminal wrapped in political legend.
- The "Indian" Ghost Dance as German PlotThis theory reflects a frontier-era fear that the 1890 Ghost Dance movement was not only a Native religious revival but a foreign-backed destabilization effort, sometimes attributed to German or other European agents. The historical record shows that U.S. officials, settlers, and newspapers often misread the movement as a precursor to insurrection, and those fears helped justify military escalation. What remains thin is evidence of actual foreign financing; the theory appears to be a rumor layered onto an existing panic about Indigenous resistance and geopolitical vulnerability.
- The "Confederate" Brazilian ColonyThis theory holds that ex-Confederate settlers in Brazil were not simply expatriate agricultural colonists but the builders of a technologically advanced Amazonian base intended for a future reconquest of the United States. The claim builds on a real migration of former Confederates to Brazil after 1865, especially to communities in São Paulo, and on the long afterlife of Confederate memory abroad. What survives in the evidence is exile, farming, and memory culture; what does not is proof of a secret industrial city or a military plan to return north and conquer.
- The "California" Sunken ContinentThis theory claims that California was once part of the lost continent of Lemuria and that the state, or large parts of it, would one day sink back beneath the Pacific. It fuses nineteenth-century lost-continent speculation with later esoteric traditions and modern earthquake fears, especially around the San Andreas Fault. The Lemuria component belongs to speculative and occult literature rather than geology, while modern scientific sources explicitly reject the idea that California is about to "fall into the ocean."
- The "Burr" Western EmpireThis theory enlarges the real Burr conspiracy into a more militarized scenario, claiming that Aaron Burr had already assembled a hidden western force capable of seizing New Orleans and launching a breakaway empire. It grows out of documented recruiting, boat-building, and supply gathering in 1805–1806, but pushes beyond the surviving record by turning an ambiguous expedition into a disciplined "shadow army." Historians generally agree that Burr sought armed support for some western venture, yet the size, readiness, and immediate New Orleans objective described in rumor literature remain unproven.
- The "Booth" SurvivalThis theory maintains that John Wilkes Booth was not killed at Garrett’s farm in April 1865 but escaped west and eventually lived under an alias in Enid, Oklahoma, often identified as David E. George. It is one of the most durable nineteenth- and early twentieth-century American survival legends, fueled by secrecy around Booth’s burial, fascination with body identification, and later sensational display culture. The Enid branch of the legend is historically important as folklore, but the mainstream record still supports Booth’s death in Virginia.
- The "Billion Dollar" CongressThis theory takes the notorious spending reputation of the 51st Congress and literalizes it into a bribery story: votes, it says, were bought with bags of gold passed on the chamber floor. The nickname "Billion-Dollar Congress" was real and reflected widespread criticism of federal spending, pensions, tariffs, and patronage under Republican control in 1889–1891. What is historically secure is the image of extravagance and corruption; what is not securely documented is a floor-level gold-for-votes mechanism in the literal form described by the theory.
- Fingerprint ForgeryThis theory held that fingerprint identification, widely presented in the early twentieth century as nearly infallible, could itself be manipulated by authorities. In its strongest form, the allegation claimed that federal investigators could reproduce a person’s friction ridges with rubber, wax, gelatin, or other molded materials and place those prints at a crime scene. The idea drew on the growing prestige of fingerprint evidence, early demonstrations that impressions could be copied, and periodic legal or press discussions about fabricated latent prints. In conspiracy form, the story usually named the FBI or modern forensic bureaus as the actors who could secretly manufacture guilt while presenting the result as scientific certainty.
- Ku Klux Klan as a Catholic False FlagThe Ku Klux Klan as a Catholic False Flag theory was a reciprocal accusation structure in which opponents on each side of America’s religious and nativist conflicts claimed that the Klan’s violence and bigotry had been engineered by the other. One version held that Catholics created or manipulated the Klan in order to disgrace Protestants and discredit anti-Catholic activism. The reverse version held that Catholics falsely portrayed the Klan’s nature or magnified it to damage Protestant public legitimacy. The theory took shape because the second Ku Klux Klan of the 1920s was overtly anti-Catholic while also presenting itself as defender of white Protestant America. That explicit anti-Catholicism made the movement both a real threat and a perfect object for inversion theories.
- Christmas Commercialization PlotThe Christmas Commercialization Plot was the belief that modern consumer Christmas was not an organic continuation of older holiday customs but a deliberate remaking of winter celebration by department stores, advertisers, illustrators, and mass retailers. In its strongest form, the theory held that the modern visual Santa—jovial, rotund, child-facing, gift-distributing, and tightly linked to store windows and shopping lists—was standardized to train children into desire and consumption. The theory drew power from a real historical process: the nineteenth-century remaking of Santa’s image through writers and illustrators, followed by the intensive use of Santa by department stores between the late nineteenth century and the 1920s. Under the conspiracy interpretation, this was not branding alone but psychological conditioning disguised as holiday magic.
- Tomb of the Unknown Soldier SecretThe Tomb of the Unknown Soldier Secret theory held that the 1921 Tomb at Arlington did not actually contain the remains publicly described, and that the true unknown war dead selected in France had been diverted for medical, anatomical, or military experimentation before an empty or substitute burial was staged for public ceremony. The theory grew from the secrecy surrounding the selection and transport process, the fact that identification was intentionally impossible, and a wider postwar environment in which military medicine and body management had become more visible. Because the ceremony of national mourning was so solemn and because the remains could not be independently verified by the public, the Tomb became susceptible to theories that the symbolic burial concealed a hidden practical use for actual bodies.
- White House SéanceThe White House Séance theory held that First Lady Florence Harding was not merely consulting astrologers and clairvoyants for personal guidance, but using a medium—most often identified in rumor as Madame Marcia Champney—to direct political decisions and influence the presidency from behind ceremonial power. The strongest historical basis for the theory lies in Florence Harding’s real consultations with Madame Marcia Champney and the publicity surrounding Champney’s alleged predictions about Warren Harding’s election and early death. The stronger version transformed astrology and occult consultation into actual governance, claiming that mediums rather than cabinet officers shaped decisions. Because the White House had a longer history of supernatural associations and because Harding’s administration was already shadowed by secrecy, scandal, and illness, the séance version proved especially durable.
- Yellow Journalism War RoomThe Yellow Journalism War Room theory held that William Randolph Hearst and Joseph Pulitzer did not simply run sensational newspapers that influenced public opinion, but maintained a literal planning room in which editorial and political operatives decided which countries would be driven toward war next. The theory emerged from the real history of yellow journalism in the 1890s and its role in inflaming public feeling during the run-up to the Spanish-American War. In its strongest form, the theory treated Hearst and Pulitzer not as publishers competing for circulation, but as strategic war-managers using press campaigns to choreograph international conflict. Because the actual press influence was dramatic enough to be historically memorable, later rumor could escalate influence into orchestration.
- The Lindbergh German ConnectionThe Lindbergh German Connection was the theory that Charles Lindbergh’s 1927 ascent from airmail pilot to global hero was not entirely organic, but was shaped by hidden German scientific, propagandistic, or even biological engineering. In its most extravagant form, Lindbergh was described not as a naturally formed American aviator but as a “constructed hero” or laboratory-made figure produced to embody discipline, endurance, and technical modernity. The theory first attached itself to the extraordinary speed with which Lindbergh became an international symbol after his New York-to-Paris flight, and later drew retrospective strength from his well-documented German associations in the 1930s. By combining early hero manufacture with later German contact, the theory turned one of aviation history’s best-known achievements into a story of engineered celebrity and foreign design.
- The Zeppelin Spy CamerasThe Zeppelin Spy Cameras theory held that German dirigibles seen over or arriving in the United States were not merely engineering marvels or passenger craft, but covert surveillance platforms gathering information on cities, industry, military sites, and, in the theory’s most extravagant form, the minds of the population below. The historical core for the theory was real: zeppelins had genuine wartime reconnaissance value, aerial photography was becoming more important, and German airships such as the Graf Zeppelin did visit the United States beginning in 1928. The more extreme “brain scanning” version extended ordinary espionage fear into the era’s broader fascination with invisible rays, mind reading, and wireless influence. In that form, the dirigible became not just a flying camera, but a floating psychological machine.
- Rudolph Valentino Fake DeathThe Rudolph Valentino Fake Death theory held that the screen idol’s 1926 death was staged or strategically managed, and that he did not truly die in New York but was instead removed from public life and retired into a hidden desert existence. In its most theatrical form, the theory claimed that the “Great Lover” was sent to a secret harem or protected retreat in an Arabian setting that mirrored the orientalist image of his greatest screen roles. The theory emerged immediately from the extraordinary scale of public mourning, the speed of rumor, and the difficulty many admirers had accepting the sudden death of a star still in his early thirties. Because Valentino’s image was already fused with desert fantasy and exotic romance, the details of the theory followed the mythology of his screen persona as much as the facts of his life.
- Silent Film SubliminalsSilent Film Subliminals was the belief that the variable frame rates and projection practices of early cinema were being exploited to place political faces, emblems, or cues into films at speeds too brief for conscious registration but strong enough to influence the subconscious. In this theory, the silent era’s nonstandard speeds—sometimes hand-cranked, sometimes projected differently from how they were shot—created an ideal technical environment for covert suggestion. The strongest version claimed that politicians’ faces or symbols could be flashed into newsreels, campaign films, or general entertainment and planted below the threshold of conscious awareness. Although the modern language of “subliminal messaging” became better known later, the core fear—that rapidly presented images could bypass conscious scrutiny—fit naturally with early cinema’s mechanical instability and political potential.
- William Desmond Taylor MurderThe William Desmond Taylor Murder theory holds that the director’s unsolved killing in February 1922 was not an isolated crime of passion, burglary, or personal dispute, but the work of a concealed Hollywood enforcement apparatus tasked with suppressing dangerous knowledge about narcotics, blackmail, and celebrity vice. Taylor’s murder became one of the defining scandals of early Hollywood, and because the case remained unsolved, it attracted layered theories almost immediately. In the “Hollywood Hit Squad” version, studio fixers, underworld intermediaries, or protected insiders removed Taylor because he knew too much about drug use and criminal exposure around stars and their circles. The theory endured because Taylor’s death landed at the exact moment when Hollywood’s glamour, vice, publicity, and vulnerability were colliding in public view.
- The Roscoe Fatty Arbuckle SacrificeThe Roscoe Fatty Arbuckle Sacrifice theory holds that the 1921 scandal surrounding comedian Roscoe “Fatty” Arbuckle was not simply a prosecution arising from the death of actress Virginia Rappe, but a coordinated public destruction designed to give anti-Hollywood reformers, moral crusaders, and industry regulators a sacrificial example. In later retellings, this coalition is sometimes described with the anachronistic label “Moral Majority,” even though the actual period actors were 1920s civic reformers, censorship advocates, church pressure groups, prosecutors, and press interests. The theory argues that Arbuckle was selected because he was highly visible, commercially successful, and symbolically useful as the embodiment of Hollywood excess. His scandal then became the lever by which the film industry could be humiliated, disciplined, and reorganized.
- The Radio Sterility PanicThe Radio Sterility Panic was the belief that the invisible wireless environment created by radio broadcasting in the 1920s was silently harming reproductive health, weakening nerves, and contributing to a broader decline in the birth rate. While demographic decline in the United States long predated mass broadcasting, and scientific evidence did not support claims of fertility damage from ordinary radio exposure, the new technology’s invisibility made it a natural target for biological fear. In its most expansive form, the theory treated radio not only as a communications system but as a diffuse sterilizing field that could alter the body without leaving visible marks. The result was one of the earliest fertility panics attached to modern electromagnetic technology.
- The Florida Land Boom ScamThe Florida Land Boom Scam was the belief that the spectacular real-estate bubble in Florida in the mid-1920s was not merely a speculative frenzy that ran out of buyers, but a deliberate banking experiment to measure how much wealth could be extracted from or erased out of the public through credit, hype, and collapse. In this theory, developers, lenders, advertisers, and financial intermediaries did not simply ride a boom; they used Florida as a contained proving ground for mass-value destruction. The historical Florida land boom was real, large, and financially destabilizing, with heavy inflows of outside money, aggressive sales culture, transport bottlenecks, and later collapse. The conspiracy version transformed those facts into a theory of elite calibration and planned financial loss.
- Federal Reserve Death WarrantThe Federal Reserve Death Warrant was the belief that American politicians who publicly promoted silver-based money, Treasury silver issuance, or broader challenges to gold and central banking placed themselves under a covert sentence of political destruction or assassination. The theory fused several different historical periods: the Free Silver movement of the late nineteenth century, later populist hostility to central banking, and twentieth-century suspicions surrounding monetary policy and political violence. In its strongest form, the theory claimed that any politician who seriously threatened the dominance of gold, banking interests, or the Federal Reserve by reviving silver would be systematically removed. The theory’s durability came from the symbolic power of silver in American anti-banker politics and from the tendency to retroactively connect monetary dissent to later assassinations.
- The 1929 Crash Managed ExitThe 1929 Crash Managed Exit was the theory that the stock-market collapse of October 1929 was not simply the bursting of a speculative bubble but a controlled event in which the biggest banking houses had already secured their own positions, reduced exposure, and prepared to profit from the public collapse. In its strongest form, the theory alleged that the “Big Five” or equivalent leading Wall Street interests had helped inflate the bubble, recognized the end in advance, and exited or hedged while small investors were still being drawn in. The historical record clearly shows a major speculative boom, a September 1929 peak, and emergency banker intervention on Black Thursday to stabilize prices. The conspiracy version turned those facts into evidence of orchestration and pre-arranged escape.
- The Teapot Dome Oil Prince PlotThe Teapot Dome Oil Prince Plot was the theory that the famous corruption scandal surrounding the secret leasing of federal naval oil reserves in the Harding administration was only the visible surface of a much larger hidden agenda. In this expanded interpretation, the bribery scandal around Albert B. Fall and oil magnates such as Edward L. Doheny and Harry F. Sinclair functioned as a deliberate distraction from a deeper geopolitical scheme—most dramatically, a plan to reverse the 1867 Alaska Purchase and transfer Alaska back into Russian hands through a concealed resource bargain. The historical Teapot Dome scandal involved secret leases, bribery, and Senate investigation, but the Alaska sale-back layer belonged to the rumor tradition that attached itself to the scandal’s exceptional corruption and secrecy.
- The Cheka in AmericaThe Cheka in America was the belief that Bolshevik terror methods had already crossed the Atlantic and that Soviet secret-police power was no longer a foreign phenomenon but an active force inside American cities. In its most dramatic form, the theory claimed that the local police in major cities such as Chicago had effectively been replaced, captured, or directed by agents operating as an American version of the Cheka. The theory emerged during the First Red Scare, when fear of Bolshevism frequently blurred distinctions between labor militancy, immigrant radicalism, police weakness, corruption, and revolutionary violence. “Cheka” became less a precise institutional label than a shorthand for hidden terror operating under municipal cover.
- The Great Anarchist NetworkThe Great Anarchist Network was the fear that the nation’s wandering poor—especially hobos riding freight trains—were not merely transient laborers or homeless travelers, but a distributed underground of trained saboteurs communicating by secret symbols and ready to attack rail lines, factories, food supplies, and towns at revolutionary command. The theory drew on two real and visible features of early twentieth-century life: the vast mobile hobo population and the existence of a practical sign system used to communicate information about food, work, police, danger, and travel. Under Red Scare conditions, those signs were reinterpreted by some observers as evidence of an organized anarchist infrastructure. In its strongest form, the theory treated every marked post, wall, or rail-side sign as a node in a national sabotage network.
- Soviet Hollywood TakeoverThe Soviet Hollywood Takeover was an early 1920s fear that the new culture of flapper films, modern romance, sexual independence, nightlife glamour, and weakened parental authority on the American screen was not merely a domestic social trend but a deliberate ideological attack directed from Moscow. In this theory, Hollywood had either been infiltrated by Bolshevik sympathizers or had become an unwitting delivery system for Soviet moral warfare. The alleged objective was the destruction of the American family unit, the erosion of traditional gender expectations, and the normalization of rebellion through mass entertainment. The theory grew in the same cultural atmosphere that produced the First Red Scare, anti-Bolshevik film propaganda, and widespread panic over youth culture in the 1920s.
- The Sacco and Vanzetti SetupThe Sacco and Vanzetti Setup theory held that Nicola Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti were not merely convicted because of anti-immigrant and anti-anarchist prejudice, but were deliberately selected for destruction because they threatened to expose corruption at higher levels of law enforcement, politics, or the justice system. The historical case already involved deep controversy over bias, procedure, and the treatment of radical defendants. The stronger setup theory extended that controversy into a hidden-motive claim: that the robbery-murder prosecution served as a cover story for silencing men connected to dangerous knowledge about official misconduct or protected criminal networks. Because the case remained a symbol of class conflict, immigrant suspicion, and judicial unfairness, it became a natural platform for more expansive corruption theories.
- The Wall Street Bombing (1920) "Inside Job"The Wall Street Bombing "Inside Job" theory holds that the September 16, 1920 bombing in New York’s financial district was either staged, facilitated, or politically exploited by authorities in order to intensify anti-radical repression during the First Red Scare. The actual bombing killed 38 people and injured hundreds, and no perpetrator was ever definitively identified. Investigators focused on anarchist suspects, and the attack quickly became part of the wider political climate surrounding bomb scares, deportations, and anti-immigrant repression. Because the case remained unsolved, alternative explanations persisted, including claims that the bombing served as a false-flag event or was allowed to happen in order to justify continuing crackdowns associated with the Palmer-era anti-radical campaign.
- The "Indian" Head Nickel PlotThis theory claimed that the Indian Head, or Buffalo, nickel carried more than national symbolism and instead concealed a coded message intended for Native uprising, resistance, or recognition. The theory has a relatively thin documentary base compared to many other early twentieth-century panics, but it emerged plausibly in a period when coin imagery, national memory, and anxiety about Native identity were heavily politicized. In rumor form, the Native profile and bison imagery of the 1913 nickel became signs of a hidden message hidden in ordinary circulation.
- The "Coca-Cola" Cocaine SecretThis theory held that Coca-Cola’s famous secret formula still contained cocaine long after the company claimed to have removed it. The theory drew strength from an important historical fact: the original drink did use coca-leaf derivatives, and cocaine was indeed part of its early formula. When the company later removed active cocaine while retaining coca-derived flavoring, the continued secrecy of the formula made it easy for the public to suspect that the drug had never truly disappeared.
- The "Automobile" as a "Rural Purge"This theory claimed that the spread of the automobile was not simply a technological change, but a city-driven campaign against the countryside. In its stronger forms, farmers argued that urban motorists, road lobbies, and machine interests were effectively purging rural life by frightening horses, crushing livestock, damaging roads, and imposing new economic burdens on farming communities. The theory grew out of real rural hostility to early motoring, documented anti-automobile associations, and repeated conflicts between farmers and drivers over roads, safety, and property.
- The "Black Hand" in AmericaThis theory held that the so-called Black Hand was not simply a loose pattern of extortion letters and local immigrant criminality, but a unified Italian “Shadow Government” exerting hidden control over the United States. The theory grew from genuine fear surrounding extortion, bombings, kidnappings, and threats in Italian immigrant communities. However, historians have shown that “Black Hand” often functioned more as a press label and panic category than as a single centralized organization.
- The "Ku Klux Klan" Masonic SchismThis theory claimed that the revived Ku Klux Klan of 1915 was not simply a nativist, white supremacist, and Protestant mass movement, but a hidden branch or schismatic form of Masonry—sometimes described polemically as a “Black Masonry” or counterfeit lodge. The claim drew on the Klan’s fraternal rituals, secrecy, graded initiations, regalia, and heavy use of lodge-like culture. In rumor form, the new Klan was imagined as an occult or rival Masonic order operating beneath its public political identity.
- The "Woman Suffrage" Jesuit PlotThis theory held that woman suffrage was not fundamentally a democratic reform, but a concealed Catholic or Jesuit strategy to increase papal influence over American politics through the votes of supposedly more devout, obedient, and church-directed women. It emerged from the overlap between the woman suffrage movement and older anti-Catholic nativism, especially in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. In conspiracy form, Protestant anti-Catholics argued that enfranchising women would not broaden liberty but create a new clerically managed voting bloc.
- The "Chicago Meat" TaintThis theory emerged in the years after Upton Sinclair’s The Jungle and held that the Chicago “Meat Trust” was not only selling adulterated meat, but was deliberately adding chemicals to sausages and processed meats to create dependence, increase repeat consumption, and mask spoilage. The theory built on real Progressive Era scandals involving preservatives, adulteration, and unsanitary meatpacking conditions. In its stronger forms, the claim treated industrial food chemistry as a system of mass bodily management rather than merely commercial fraud.
- The "Christian Science" Mind ControlThis theory claimed that Mary Baker Eddy and Christian Science did not merely teach spiritual healing, but exercised direct and often harmful control over the minds of followers. In polemical language, Eddy was sometimes described as draining will, judgment, or vitality from adherents, which later rumor compressed into the image of a “mental vampire.” The theory drew strength from real Christian Science teachings about mind, healing, animal magnetism, and mental malpractice, together with a long public history of accusations that the movement fostered dependency, irrationality, or psychic domination.
- The "Teddy Roosevelt" Third Party SabotageThis theory claimed that Theodore Roosevelt’s 1912 Progressive, or “Bull Moose,” campaign was covertly backed by high finance—especially J.P. Morgan interests—not to elect Roosevelt, but to split the Republican vote and guarantee Woodrow Wilson’s victory. The theory draws on a real electoral effect: the Republican split did enable Wilson to win with a plurality. It also draws on the documented role of wealthy Progressive financiers, especially George W. Perkins, a former Morgan partner, in funding the new party. In conspiracy form, these facts become evidence of deliberate sabotage orchestrated by big business.
- The Prohibition "Liquor-Poisoning" PlotThis theory held that the federal government intentionally poisoned industrial alcohol during Prohibition in order to kill or disable people who drank illegal liquor. Unlike many panic narratives, this one rests on a substantial documentary foundation: federal policy did require more dangerous denaturing formulas for industrial alcohol, and those formulas contributed to deaths when bootleggers reprocessed or diverted industrial spirits for drinking. The conspiracy form of the theory extends this into a broader claim that the state knowingly accepted mass death as an enforcement strategy.
- The "Gold" DrainThis theory claims that British financial interests were quietly drawing gold out of the United States in the early twentieth century in order to build the foundation of a future supranational monetary institution, later retroactively identified as a kind of "world bank." The theory draws on genuine transatlantic gold movements, wartime bullion shipments, and the rise of international central-bank cooperation. In conspiracy form, those developments are interpreted not as normal features of the gold standard and war finance, but as deliberate steps toward an internationalized banking order built at America’s expense.
- The Income Tax SlaveryThis theory claims that the Sixteenth Amendment was never lawfully ratified and that the federal income tax was imposed through procedural fraud in order to bind Americans to permanent taxation, federal debt, and future war finance. It became especially visible in twentieth-century tax-protester movements, though it draws on much earlier hostility to income taxation and centralized federal revenue collection. The theory attaches particular significance to the year 1913, linking the Sixteenth Amendment, the Federal Reserve Act, and the approach of World War I into a single plot narrative.
- The "Rothschild" Takeover of the USThis theory claims that the Federal Reserve Act of 1913 ended American financial independence by placing the nation under the indirect control of foreign banking interests, most commonly personified by the Rothschild family. The theory draws on real controversies about who should control currency, credit, and reserves, but it expands those debates into a claim that a foreign banking network effectively captured the American state.
- The Jekyll Island SecretThis theory holds that the November 1910 meeting at Jekyll Island was not merely a technical banking conference, but a covert attempt by major financiers and allied policymakers to design a new monetary regime that would place the United States permanently under debt-based control. The theory draws on a real secret meeting attended by Senator Nelson W. Aldrich, Treasury official A. Piatt Andrew, and leading bankers including Paul Warburg, Henry P. Davison, Frank A. Vanderlip, and Arthur Shelton. Because the participants traveled quietly, used first names, and worked outside public view, the conference became one of the most durable foundations for later claims that the Federal Reserve was born through financial conspiracy rather than public reform.
- The "Yellow Journalism" WarThis theory held that William Randolph Hearst and Joseph Pulitzer did not merely exploit the Spanish-American War in their papers but effectively manufactured or “invented” the war in order to sell newspapers. It grew out of the very real circulation war between the New York Journal and the New York World, both of which sensationalized events in Cuba and competed aggressively for public attention. Later retellings compressed this complicated media and policy environment into a single accusation: the war happened because newspapers wanted it to happen.
- The "Papal" Invasion of the MidwestThis theory held that the Catholic buildup in Cincinnati was not simply diocesan growth but the construction of a fortified inland base from which the papacy could relocate and extend direct power into the American interior. It arose from nineteenth-century anti-Catholic and nativist fears surrounding church property, immigration, episcopal authority, and the rapid institutional growth of the Diocese and later Archdiocese of Cincinnati. In rumor form, churches, seminaries, convents, and schools became parts of a "fortress" city said to be prepared for the Pope.
- The "Machine" ElectionThis theory claimed that the earliest mechanical voting machines contained hidden gears, counters, or programmed tricks that could quietly transfer votes from one candidate to another, sometimes described as flipping every tenth vote. It emerged almost immediately after the introduction of lever voting machines in the 1890s, when reformers presented them as solutions to ballot stuffing and intimidation while skeptics worried that unseen mechanisms merely moved fraud inside the box. The historical record confirms early suspicion and debate over machine integrity, but not a documented system in which machines were built to shift every tenth vote by design.
- The "Sugar" Trust PoisonThis theory claimed that refined industrial sugar was not merely nutritionally dubious but chemically manipulated to make consumers weaker, more compliant, or more docile. It grew from the broader late nineteenth-century crisis of food adulteration, the rise of the American Sugar Refining Company, and deep suspicion of industrial processing. The historical record supports real concern about adulterants, bleaching agents, and deceptive food chemistry, but it does not establish a program in which sugar was intentionally laced to pacify the public.
- The "Diamond" Hoax of 1872This theory claimed that the Great Diamond Hoax was exposed publicly only to conceal a genuine diamond discovery that government-connected figures or powerful investors had quietly seized for themselves. The historical basis is the real 1872 diamond hoax, in which salted ground and planted gemstones convinced prominent investors that a spectacular western American mine had been found. The documentary record strongly supports the conclusion that the episode was a fraud, but the speed with which officials and experts moved to close the matter later encouraged the claim that the "hoax" label itself was a cover story.
- The "Wheat" CornerThis theory held that a single speculator in Chicago could use hidden communications, coded telegrams, and control of grain supply to determine the price of bread worldwide. It was especially associated with the great wheat corners of the late nineteenth century, above all Joseph Leiter's 1897-1898 campaign in Chicago. The historical record confirms that major speculators could influence wheat prices dramatically and that telegraph codes were widely used in finance, but the notion that one man permanently commanded the "hunger of the world" belongs to the rhetoric of anti-speculation rather than to a stable global system of control.
- The "Silver" Judas PlotThis theory claimed that the Coinage Act of 1873, later denounced as the "Crime of 73," was not a technical monetary reform but a deliberate betrayal designed to contract the money supply, impoverish the United States, and place the country within the grasp of foreign finance, especially the Rothschild banking dynasty. The historical basis lies in the genuine fury that followed the demonetization of the standard silver dollar amid falling prices and debt pressure. The record clearly shows that many Americans believed they had been betrayed by hidden interests, but the specific claim of a coordinated Rothschild purchase plan belongs to the conspiracy tradition of the free-silver era.
- The "Standard Oil" ArsonThis theory claimed that refinery fires and explosions affecting independent oil companies were not ordinary industrial accidents but deliberate acts connected to Standard Oil. The story drew strength from the company's documented use of aggressive tactics such as railroad rebates, pipeline pressure, acquisitions, and market warfare, which made contemporaries willing to believe that any suspicious disaster was "Rockefeller's match." The historical record supports the climate of fear and distrust around Standard Oil, but it does not establish a general, proven pattern in which the company systematically burned competitors' refineries.
- The "Vagrancy" ArmyThis theory held that the growing number of "tramps" after the Panic of 1873 were not simply unemployed wanderers but a covert advance guard for revolutionary disorder, sometimes described as a communist scout network moving across the country. The theory emerged in the context of mass unemployment, the Great Railroad Strike of 1877, and a broader fear that mobility itself had become politically dangerous. Contemporary writing often blended tramps, strikers, outsiders, and radicals into a single threatening figure, creating the image of an organized vagrant army.
- The "Opium" KidnappingThis theory claimed that Chinese laundries and related urban spaces used mysterious "steam," fumes, or chemical vapors to incapacitate passersby and pull them into hidden systems of confinement, addiction, or servitude. It emerged from a wider anti-Chinese panic that linked laundries, opium dens, interracial contact, and urban vice. The surviving record shows extensive racist folklore around Chinese businesses and opium, but the specific kidnapping-by-steam narrative belongs primarily to the history of urban legend, yellow-peril propaganda, and moral panic.
- The "Bachelor" Tax PlotThis theory holds that proposed bachelor taxes were not merely moral or fiscal measures, but part of a broader state effort to pressure men into marriage and childbearing in order to increase the labor supply for industrial society. The idea draws on real historical proposals to tax unmarried men, especially in periods of anxiety about declining birthrates, social disorder, and national strength. In conspiracy-oriented retellings, these proposals become evidence that government and industrial elites wanted to eliminate bachelorhood as an obstacle to producing more future workers.